Showing posts with label physician. Show all posts
Showing posts with label physician. Show all posts

19 August 2007

oscar the cat

by now, i'm sure you're aware that i love animals, particularly cats. my mom (thanks mom!) sent me an article last week that summarized a publication in the new england journal of medicine. i felt i should share. enjoy!
--

A Day in the Life of Oscar the Cat
David M. Dosa, M.D., M.P.H.


Oscar the Cat awakens from his nap, opening a single eye to survey his kingdom. From atop the desk in the doctor's charting area, the cat peers down the two wings of the nursing home's advanced dementia unit. All quiet on the western and eastern fronts. Slowly, he rises and extravagantly stretches his 2-year-old frame, first backward and then forward. He sits up and considers his next move.

In the distance, a resident approaches. It is Mrs. P., who has been living on the dementia unit's third floor for 3 years now. She has long forgotten her family, even though they visit her almost daily. Moderately disheveled after eating her lunch, half of which she now wears on her shirt, Mrs. P. is taking one of her many aimless strolls to nowhere. She glides toward Oscar, pushing her walker and muttering to herself with complete disregard for her surroundings. Perturbed, Oscar watches her carefully and, as she walks by, lets out a gentle hiss, a rattlesnake-like warning that says "leave me alone." She passes him without a glance and continues down the hallway. Oscar is relieved. It is not yet Mrs. P.'s time, and he wants nothing to do with her.

Oscar jumps down off the desk, relieved to be once more alone and in control of his domain. He takes a few moments to drink from his water bowl and grab a quick bite. Satisfied, he enjoys another stretch and sets out on his rounds. Oscar decides to head down the west wing first, along the way sidestepping Mr. S., who is slumped over on a couch in the hallway. With lips slightly pursed, he snores peacefully — perhaps blissfully unaware of where he is now living. Oscar continues down the hallway until he reaches its end and Room 310. The door is closed, so Oscar sits and waits. He has important business here.

Twenty-five minutes later, the door finally opens, and out walks a nurse's aide carrying dirty linens. "Hello, Oscar," she says. "Are you going inside?" Oscar lets her pass, then makes his way into the room, where there are two people. Lying in a corner bed and facing the wall, Mrs. T. is asleep in a fetal position. Her body is thin and wasted from the breast cancer that has been eating away at her organs. She is mildly jaundiced and has not spoken in several days. Sitting next to her is her daughter, who glances up from her novel to warmly greet the visitor. "Hello, Oscar. How are you today?"

Oscar takes no notice of the woman and leaps up onto the bed. He surveys Mrs. T. She is clearly in the terminal phase of illness, and her breathing is labored. Oscar's examination is interrupted by a nurse, who walks in to ask the daughter whether Mrs. T. is uncomfortable and needs more morphine. The daughter shakes her head, and the nurse retreats. Oscar returns to his work. He sniffs the air, gives Mrs. T. one final look, then jumps off the bed and quickly leaves the room. Not today.

Making his way back up the hallway, Oscar arrives at Room 313. The door is open, and he proceeds inside. Mrs. K. is resting peacefully in her bed, her breathing steady but shallow. She is surrounded by photographs of her grandchildren and one from her wedding day. Despite these keepsakes, she is alone. Oscar jumps onto her bed and again sniffs the air. He pauses to consider the situation, and then turns around twice before curling up beside Mrs. K.

One hour passes. Oscar waits. A nurse walks into the room to check on her patient. She pauses to note Oscar's presence. Concerned, she hurriedly leaves the room and returns to her desk. She grabs Mrs. K.'s chart off the medical-records rack and begins to make phone calls.

Within a half hour the family starts to arrive. Chairs are brought into the room, where the relatives begin their vigil. The priest is called to deliver last rites. And still, Oscar has not budged, instead purring and gently nuzzling Mrs. K. A young grandson asks his mother, "What is the cat doing here?" The mother, fighting back tears, tells him, "He is here to help Grandma get to heaven." Thirty minutes later, Mrs. K. takes her last earthly breath. With this, Oscar sits up, looks around, then departs the room so quietly that the grieving family barely notices.

On his way back to the charting area, Oscar passes a plaque mounted on the wall. On it is engraved a commendation from a local hospice agency: "For his compassionate hospice care, this plaque is awarded to Oscar the Cat." Oscar takes a quick drink of water and returns to his desk to curl up for a long rest. His day's work is done. There will be no more deaths today, not in Room 310 or in any other room for that matter. After all, no one dies on the third floor unless Oscar pays a visit and stays awhile.

Note: Since he was adopted by staff members as a kitten, Oscar the Cat has had an uncanny ability to predict when residents are about to die. Thus far, he has presided over the deaths of more than 25 residents on the third floor of Steere House Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Providence, Rhode Island. His mere presence at the bedside is viewed by physicians and nursing home staff as an almost absolute indicator of impending death, allowing staff members to adequately notify families. Oscar has also provided companionship to those who would otherwise have died alone. For his work, he is highly regarded by the physicians and staff at Steere House and by the families of the residents whom he serves.


Source Information

Dr. Dosa is a geriatrician at Rhode Island Hospital and an assistant professor of medicine at the Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University — both in Providence.

PubMed Citation

03 August 2007

the most prevalent question: what's a d.o.?

i don't know if i've explicitly mentioned this before, but i'm an osteopathic medical student.

wtf does that mean?

i'm sure you're wondering.

in the u.s., there are two different types of physicians who are licensed as medical doctors. one group everyone knows about. these are the doctors who have "m.d." posted behind their names. (m.d. = medical doctor) they comprise, at present, the majority of physicians in the country. the medical schools that provide m.d. degrees are known as allopathic medical schools. the other group is lesser known. these are the doctors who have "d.o." posted behind their names. (d.o. = doctor of osteopathy) they comprise, at present, the majority of medical students in the country. the medical schools that provide d.o. degrees are known as osteopathic medical schools.

what does all this mean? well, truthfully, it depends upon who you ask. the history of how osteopathy came about and split from allopathy is one that proves quite complex. interesting, no doubt--but way beyond the scope of what i can explain here. historically, osteopathic medicine has proven more "holistic" than allopathic medicine. many (if not most) of allopathic physicians would say, however, that allopathic medicine is more grounded in medical science than osteopathic medicine. as with any fine splitting of hairs in a discipline, the two sides tend to bash each other quite a bit. this is unfortunate, because in reality, both types of practitioners and students have tremendous expertise that they could share with each other if they'd get over the notion that one type of doctor is "better" than another.

given the increase in awareness on both sides of the educational divide regarding "alternative" medical practices, today's medical school graduates are, imho, all equal. some people would argue with this--after all, is getting a degree from man's best medical school the same as getting a degree from man's worst medical school? i argue that either notion is fiction. there really aren't "opposites" in medical schools in terms of best and worst. some schools have better programs in certain areas than others, some have more research opportunities, some have superior clinical opportunities, some have different styles of instruction, etc. the old notion that some schools are better because they've attracted more students with 4.0 gpas and scores of 35+ on the mcat...these "predictors" (as they're dubbed by med school admissions committees) are rather arbitrary. of the thousands of people who apply to medical school, only about 1/10th actually get a seat at a school. i highly doubt that there's any "dumb" person amongst those who get in. in fact, it's arguable as to whether or not any applicants could be considered "dumb"--anyone who applies is hyper-educated, at the very least. also, as anyone who has been through the process can tell you, there's a point at which an applicant realizes that s/he doesn't care where s/he gets to go to school--everyone who gets in is simply grateful to be able to go. so, do the students at mbms have higher iq's than those at mwms? probably. does this mean they'll end up becoming better physicians? hell no.

in my opinion, it matters little which type of doctor one is or where one did her or his training. the important thing is how a physician practices.

nevertheless, the most oft asked question of an osteopathic medical student is "what is a d.o.?" everyone asks this question. some more than once. the students at my school have been talking about this all week. how do we answer this question? what is the difference? what do we want people to know?

a group of osteopathic physicians in california, in collaboration with two osteopathic medical schools in that state, created the following youtube video as a response. it's a little bit commercial-y for my taste, but it gives a very basic overview.






other than this, there are a few details about osteopathic physicians that i'll delineate here, particularly since they're often misunderstood:
  1. d.o.s are licensed by the same medical board(s) as m.d.s
  2. the curriculum in an allopathic medical school differs from a curriculum in an osteopathic medical school only by one class: d.o. students are required to spend the first two years studying osteopathic practices (osteopathic practices are similar to techniques used by a chiropractor, a physical therapist, or a massage therapist, etc.--i.e. they're hands-on techniques used to treat dysfunctions of the musculoskeletal system)
  3. d.o.s and m.d.s, for the most part, end up doing residencies together (so their training is identical in the post-graduate sense)
  4. d.o.s and m.d.s do the exact same things, ranging from performing a school physical on a kid in family practice to conducting a heart-lung transplant operation in surgery
  5. the "holistic" philosophy to which d.o.'s subscribe is defined as follows:
    1. the body is a unit; the person is a unit of body, mind, and spirit
    2. the body is capable of self-regulation, self-healing and health maintenance
    3. structure and function are reciprocally interrelated
    4. rational treatment is based upon an understanding of the basic principles of body unity, self-regulation, and the interrelationship of structure and function
so, there's my brief answer to the most prevalent question. if you find it helpful/interesting, please pass it on!

18 June 2007

the ponderous patient: the magic needle

in the continuing saga of my lack-of-a-gallbladder sod dysfunction, mr_dr_do suggested that i see an acupuncturist/traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) physician. i'd been to an acupressurist in college, but never to an acupuncturist. this was largely because, up until the last few years, i'd been terrified of needles. not to mention that i was a tad skeptical--in my years as a patient, the number of times i've been asked to purchase extras (i.e. herbs, vitamins, supplements, salves, etc.) from a physician has been directly proportional to how close one adheres to "western" medicine. in other words, the more "alternative" the practitioner, the more extras one has to buy, and therefore, the more expensive the overall treatment becomes. since i have some ethical qualms about whether physicians should sell products in their offices (a rant i'll indulge in at a later date), it's turned me off a bit to "alternative" pracitioners.* nevertheless, i'm curious about "integrative" medicine and what it can offer. so i decided, in spite of my fears about the costs, to pursue this course of treatment.


mr_dr_do clearly spent a considerable amount of time looking for an appropriate referral and came up with a female physician at a local college of acupuncture, whom i'll name here as dr_tcm. three weeks ago, i went to see dr_tcm for the first time. i liked her instantly (she personally came to the waiting room to get me! who does that?!?)--during the first appointment, i discovered that she's witty, intelligent, cogent, and thoughtful. she'd also been a medical doctor (md) in china, then came to the u.s. and got a ph.d. in endocrinology. this made our encounter all the more interesting because she knows the difference between which types of medicine work best in which situations. she's now one of the main faculty physicians at a local college of tcm.


she didn't promise me the world: "i don't have any magic needles!" she said. but she noted that she has worked on many patients who had various g.i. complaints following surgeries like mine and, based on her experience with them, felt that she could help me.


if somebody had told me that laying on a table naked with needles stuck in various parts of my body would help me feel better, i would have called him/her a fruitcake. i mean, seriously, can you imagine? it sounds like quack.


only, it's not.


when i appeared for my first session, i rated my pain and nausea at 4/10 (10 being highest). by the end of the session, i had *no* pain or nausea. at first i wondered if i'd merely not realized that lying down helps with the pain/nausea (i spent about 1.5 hours laying on the table with the needles in me). but the symptoms were better the next day, too. this continued--i noticed that after every session, i felt better. it didn't mean that my symptoms stopped completely--they haven't--but i've found some relief that doesn't involve massive amounts of heavy-duty medications or life-altering surgeries. how cool is that?!?!?


i did end up buying some products (the "pancakes" of chinese herbs she's given me to put on my abdomen at night were just too neat to pass up--i'd never seen anything like that before, even though "western" medicine now uses a transdermal approach frequently, so i was curious to try them). but most of what dr_tcm has suggested (prescribed?) has proven to be relatively straightforward. some of it, in fact, has been so straightforward that i've felt like smacking myself in the head for not thinking about it myself.


case in point: since surgery, i've been completely intolerant to food that contains fat. (i'm not going to delineate what intolerant means in this context--use your imagination.) so i've dropped all fat containing foods from my diet and had been eating a relatively "raw" diet--that is, i was only eating stuff that, if left on my kitchen counter for any period of time, would go bad (e.g. organic fruits & veggies, etc.). i always had been under the impression that such a diet is about the healthiest one a person can follow. (the only upside to this whole process is that i've dropped about 15 lbs and now weigh close to what i did in college; i don't recommend this as a weight loss program...but at least something good has come of it...i never imagined i'd have a flat tummy again!) the first thing that dr_tcm asked me to do, though, was to change my diet! needless to say, i was perplexed when she asked me to do this. but then she told me what she wanted me to do: eat foods that had been cooked, because the compounds in them would already be broken down a bit and thus would require less effort for my body to digest. she also asked me not to eat anything cold--only hot foods. puzzled by this, i asked my favorite question: why? and then she noted a basic science concept--the cold would make my gut seize as my body tried to regulate its internal temperature. duh, i thought, why didn't i think of that? what's more basic to science than the notion of how temperature is transferred and its effects? apparently, there's a reason i didn't major in science in college....


needless to say, between the diet, the funny herb pancakes, and the acupuncture sessions themselves, i've been beginning--albeit slowly--to feel better. i've got my fingers crossed in the hope that this will last. as she said, there are no magic needles in her arsenal...but there's something profound in her treatments, that's for sure. it's magic enough for me. :-)

....

recently, grey's anatomy had an episode in which they depicted acupuncture. it's a wonderful vignette on what having tcm done for the first time is like--particularly in this country. i hope you enjoy the video as much as i did! :-)











....

*a note on language: i have a strong dislike for the manner in which the english language has been used to name various medical practices. i don't believe that "western" medicine is better than "eastern" medicine; i have difficulties calling u.s. physicians (m.d.s or d.o.s) "traditional" given that tcm and other such practices have been around for many a millennia longer than the medicine we think of as traditional today; and, overall, i'm not the type to think in terms of opposing forces. mwms has just assigned us a new textbook for the upcoming year called "integrative medicine." it discusses the problematic aspects of the terminologies and suggests the term integrative to describe what practitioners with an "holistic" (<--another problematic term) perspective practice/perceive such medicine to be. i personally don't know the best way to describe these different types of medicine--hence i'll put the terms in quotation marks to indicate that they're not terms i've created/i'm not using them as labels.

29 May 2007

picking up the thread: is it worth it?

first i must note that my beloved mac is finally back in my possession. i might not let it out of my sight again--that was one long tough week without it! i must thank the mac geniuses--they replaced both my fans, gratis. now the only periodic odd noise i hear is the sound of my cat, biddle, growling at the fed-ups man. did i mention that my cat thinks she's a dog? ;-)

....

i've spent a considerable amount of time lately pondering my pursuit of higher education. i'm not questioning the thirst for knowledge itself, mind you, but the actual paying-of-tuition / sitting-in-classes / eventually-getting-degree part of this whole journey to become a physician. choosing to delay my education for another year has left me feeling a bit depressed. this year, when (if?) i start medical school again, i'll be 30. i know chronological age is essentially meaningless (unless you're an actuary), but for some reason, i feel odd about this fact of turning 30. it's a petty thing, really--i'm experiencing that "always on the outside looking in on other's lives" syndrome that accompanies one of those life moments when everyone i come into contact with seems to have something that i want, yet lack. you know these people: they have the mcjob or the mchouse or the mcpartner or the mcbaby or the mcdog or...the real clincher for me these days...the mchealth. some people i come into contact with even have all of these things, including the mchappiness. i guess they got all the mcluck, too, eh?

the envy i feel probably stems most from having too much time to think. but recently, i realized that i'm not the only one gnawing on these feelings and issues, particularly as they relate to medical school and the sacrifice it entails. this is where i catch onto the thread--dr_panda_bear asked the question first, as far as i can tell, and dr_urostream mentioned it next--and so i might as well audibly voice the question that ricochets through the head of every med student as they hit yet another bump in the road: is it worth it?

it's a heavy question. one might think, based upon my recent "toad list" post where i ranted about some of the worst physicians on record, that i have a negative view of the medical profession. the truth is the opposite: i tend (to a fault?) to see the positive first. i'm a bit of an idealist in this way...and a tad gullible, i suspect, too. it's been difficult for me to answer questions posed to me about medical school and whether it's worth all the time/effort/energy/money/sacrifice/stress/etc. the other bloggers do a great job of addressing the issues in their posts--i wish i could write so cogently and analytically in response to the question.
....

when i ponder the question as to whether or not it's worth it for me to continue medical school, a certain experience comes to mind--the one that confirmed my convictions about being called to this career path. the story, i believe, speaks for itself:

when i first became interested in a career in medicine, one of my physicians, fertile_doc, hired me to work as the slave in his office for the summer. i spent most of my first few weeks on the job culling the thirty years of medical records and journals that were beginning to eat up all the storage space in the office. toward the end of the summer, though, i began doing more clerical work and having some interaction with patients.

the office was chronically busy, particularly on mornings when the ultrasound technician was present, as the majority of fertile_doc's practice surrounded treating couples with infertility issues and ultrasound plays a key role in this process. on one such morning, we were running a tad late. the waiting room was crowded and the staff was bustling about, trying to get all the phones answered, labs drawn, and insurance forms organized. i'd been assigned to "man the window," checking in patients and making sure charts made it to the appropriate spots on the racks for triage. and i was at the point where i was beginning to feel truly frazzled....

in the midst of this, someone knocked on the window. i groaned silently to myself; i'd thought all the morning's patients had been checked in already. what now? i was prepared to give my memorized, automaton directions to the bathroom, insurance policies, etc. i feared i'd strangle a drug rep if they appeared in the midst of our busiest hours. but i opened the window and was quite puzzled by what i saw. an elderly woman sat in a wheelchair with her husband standing behind her. they were definitely not the sort of people who'd show up for infertility treatment and i wondered as to whether they'd wandered into the wrong office. this was a situation that was going to require me to think. carefully.

"does fertile_doc work here?" the woman asked.
"uh...yes." i replied, still feeling puzzled.
"is fertile_doc here now?"
"yes" i replied. "do you have an appointment?"
"no" she said, "but i would like to speak to him."
"I'd be happy to schedule an appointment for you."
the woman looked at me--my confusion was no doubt clear by this point--and then struggled to pull herself up out of the wheelchair until she was standing. now eye-to-eye with me, she said:
"twenty-four years ago, fertile_doc detected my breast cancer during a routine exam. i survived because he discovered it early. i'm here because i would like to thank him."
she then carefully lowered herself back down into the wheelchair.

a few minutes later, i watched as this woman thanked fertile_doc for
what he'd done. most physicians i'd known treated breast exams as a perfunctory part of the physical examination. it's another one of those areas in which technology (in this case, mammography) often replaces good hands-on examination in medicine. but fertile_doc always took this portion of the exam seriously, taking time to really look and feel for lumps and changes in breast tissue. now i knew why he did so. it was a profound lesson.

as i watched this frail woman give fertile_doc a hug, i discovered something even more profound: fertile_doc had given this woman more time--time to be with her children, her husband, her loved ones...time to live. with one small, attentive act in the midst of an everyday job, fertile_doc made a huge difference in this woman's life.

it was in that moment, watching this interaction unfold, that i realized that there was nothing more meaningful i could do with my life than follow a career that had the potential to give even one person an extra minute, day, month, year, of quality life.

is anything worth more than that opportunity?

....

the answer for me, to the question "is it worth it?" is a simple resounding yes. in spite of all the bullsh!t that surrounds medicine these days, I believe it is a privilege to become a physician.
....

to all those physicians who have taken care of me, my loved ones, and even (especially?) the homeless jane & john does on the street: thank you for choosing to make the sacrifice, to dive in, & serve by example to show students that the pursuit of medicine is, indeed, worth it.

23 May 2007

the ponderous patient: the list

in the midst of my appointment with mr_dr_do today, he wondered aloud as to where he was on my "list." for some reason, he thinks i have a list of physicians in some sort of order--like my own personal rankings. lol. i've been a patient for a long time, but i don't make a habit of going back to "repeat offenders." nevertheless, i've since been pondering this list notion and have decided it would be pretty funny to give out some "awards," particularly to a few choice physicians whom i sincerely hope are no longer in practice anymore or that i hope have since learned not to do what they did to me and/or to my friends/relatives/etc. i certainly can't and won't mention names...but there may prove to be some great healing humor in this. feel free to add your own favorites! :-)

toad awards:

  • worst doctor ever award: dr_suicide. dr_suicide was my friend's psychiatrist. he wins the worst doctor ever award for telling my friend, during a suicidal episode, that life would never get better and that it would always be bad. needless to say, my friend attempted suicide after that appointment. that's a hell of a way to lighten a case load!
  • worst pelvic exam award: dr_3_fingers. this particular er doc performed a bimanual exam that nearly made me jump off the examining table. his response to my distress: "sorry, i'll only use two fingers next time."
  • worst rectal exam award: dr_gi_partner. this gi doc was a partner of a gi doc i had during one of my surgeries. put it this way: he must have learned in anatomy that you can palpate the brain through the rectum. enough said.
  • needs to remediate english award: dr_doogie. dr_doogie was a very young o.b./g.y.n. assigned to me at a small town hospital when i was in college. i discovered, upon obtaining my medical records, that he did not know the difference between an adjective and a noun. it's "virgin," you idiot, not "virginal." at least, not unless the patient's name happens to be mary and the year is 33 b.c.e.!
  • worst bedside manner: dr_old_gyn_surgeon. i heard the doctor i was seeing for an acute surgical problem talk to this guy in the hallway while i was still in the exam room (where the partner, who gets the worst bedside manner runner-up award, had left me in stirrups!). he'd never met me--didn't know anything about me except my age--and managed to blurt out: "well, if we go in there now, we'll have to take 1/2 her ovary. then in two years, we'll have to take the other 1/2. two years after that, we'll have to take the other, and, by the time she's 30 and wants to have kids, there will be nothing left!" he then flies into the room and proceeds to probe me with the ultrasound machine. (note to future doctors: don't assume that (a) every woman wants to reproduce, (b) every woman is straight, and (c) if you're a gyn, that every adenexal mass in a 20-something is ovarian--it was my *appendix* they were seeing on the scan, *not* my ovary. i'd have *died* if they hadn't done surgery. can't have kids if i'm dead, you know?)
  • most outrageous solicitation award: dr_repro_endo, in new England. no, i will not buy the cholesterol supplements that your husband has left medical practice to sell. i will not buy them even if you say you won't treat me unless i take them. if you want to sell stuff, join Amway.
  • sexist award: dr_teeth. i hate to break it to this guy, but having a statue of a "lady in distress" being saved by an oral surgeon does *not* earn him a vote of confidence from a woman, even if he was born before 1920.
  • w "family values" award: dr_teen_ob. my friend, who had a baby when she was in her teens and living in a small town, delivered her baby in the presence of this doctor, who gave her a completely unnecessary grade 4 episiotomy. i'm usually not the type to promote revenge, but i hope this guy ends up as my friend's patient...with a very embarrassing problem. have issues with teen pregnancy? then don't go into obstetrics!
those are just the ones that i can think of off the top of my head. there have been more, many more...i'll add more later....

[oh, and mr_dr_do, if you happen to have found my blog and are reading this, you no doubt now realize that you're nowhere near to getting on this particular list! don't worry!]

18 April 2007

rant ii: the government versus a woman's body

the supreme court released its decision re: partial birth abortion today. i wish i could provide a direct link to the court document, but it's a rather large pdf file, and i have nowhere on the web to store it myself. so if you're interested in the nitty gritty of what i'm about to say, you may want to go read that document first. now has a link to it in their news section, as do several other news pages and organizations.

if you've been reading my blog, you know by now that i consider myself a feminist. i tend to agree with liberal politics, primarily because i'm an academic at heart and i'm always questioning everything. (my favorite question growing up: why?) i believe that conventions are made to be questioned and analyzed, not reflexively followed. i also am an exceptionally sensitive person, one who holds life dearly enough that she's been known to run into traffic to save a turtle about to meet its demise by attempting to cross the street. i cried when someone killed the wasps outside my house recently, even though i was afraid of them (i don't like pain and therefore avoid critters that sting/bite/want to eat me). basically, i'm a big mush--my heart is always on my sleeve and, no matter how hard i try, i cannot conceal this fact.

that having been said, i struggle with the issue of abortion. i feel that life is sacred. i've always been fascinated by childbirth and i know i'll likely end up focusing my career on women's health. *and* i have a strong respect for women's bodies and their choices about what happens to their bodies. so although i don't think i could ever have an abortion myself (<--i'm a little biased because i have fertility problems and it would be pretty darn hard for me to get pregnant without medical intervention), i think every woman has a right to choose. i also acknowledge the fact that, given my interest in women's health care, i may be trained and/or asked to perform this procedure. this fact scares me, but i acknowledge the reality, nonetheless. i cannot imagine the suffering that an unwanted child must endure throughout his or her life. i also don't think any woman should be forced into poverty or put her life in jeopardy for a fetus. it's my opinion, plain and simple.

when i first heard about partial birth abortion, i was incredibly disgusted. the description of the procedure seemed absolutely horrific to me and i couldn't understand why anyone would ever want to have that kind of an abortion. then i read the supreme court ruling.

if i'm understanding it correctly, a partial birth abortion involves delivering the fetus to a certain point and then killing it. in contrast, other types of late-term abortion involve dis-membering the fetus in utero and then delivering it. knowing what i know about science (remember, i just studied embryology and neuroanatomy, among other things), if i had to choose between someone whacking me on the head to kill me versus tearing me to shreds, i'd choose to be whacked. it's not even in the realm of being contestable--one act causes immediate death, the other is pure torture. but what did the courts just do? they just prevented physicians from performing the "humane" form of abortion while permitting them to torture fetuses via the alternate method. they say they're trying to preserve the sanctity of life--how on earth does this decision uphold that sanctity? seriously! can anyone follow the logic here? or did they simply make the decision so ambiguous as to prevent providers from performing any late-term abortions? hmm....

i really don't understand how the same government that has allowed us to invade other countries where we are killing innocent children and that allows our children to access guns so that they can kill each other can take a stand against killing a fetus that cannot survive outside of its mother. i also don't understand how our government can refuse to allow sex education to be taught in schools. if they don't want women to have abortions, then why aren't they teaching pregnancy prevention? if they're professing abstinence as a "cure" to prevent pregnancy, then why is the government (in some states) requiring young girls to be vaccinated against sti's? if they truly believed in their abstinence programs, there would be no need for the vaccinations. oh, wait--that's right--boys can have all the sex they want and spread around the sti's while girls have to remain abstinent until marriage wherein they get exposed to sti's because the guys were sleeping around--that's why we're mandating the vaccines, right?

i swear, if it weren't for the right to free speech, i think i'd be on the next plane out of this country. until the government takes away my right to rant, though, they'll just have to deal with me screaming from my blogspot.

01 April 2007

the paradox of perspective

a few days ago, my friend j.p. blogged about her frustrations with the healthcare system and being a patient in it. today i discovered a recent blog entry from dr_couz (a FP resident in Canada who writes a wonderful blog about her experiences in residency there) discussing the lines physicians must draw between their personal and professional lives. now here i sit, pondering the paradoxical perspectives.

on one hand, dr_couz's commentary on boundaries hits me hard. i have a hard time keeping and maintaing boundaries (but, no, i don't have a "caretaker" personality or anything! ;-) ) and i've watched many a physician get burned by an inability to balance work and life or friends and patients--or both. most recently, a wonderful geriatrician spoke to our class after her last day in private practice. she's hardly retirement age; yet, she's retiring. when describing why she's chosen to take "time out" from being a physician, she told us a story about how she recently sent her husband to a patient's house to fix the patient's leaky shower head. yes, we live in an area where there are many elderly people in need of assistance in one form or another--but it took her getting that involved in her patients' lives to realize why she had burnt out. she simply became over-involved. this physician stood in front of my class and told us, point blank, to maintain our boundaries. she's a sobering example of what can happen when one crosses too many lines.

so, i get that i'll need to be cautious when i go into practice (if i ever get there!), because i know i have tendencies to be like this geriatrician, to want to fix everything. [i'm pretty good with a wrench and plumber's tape, actually. ;-) ] but i also must wonder, what about the fire?

my friend j.p. eloquently captured her rage at the healthcare system and at doctors in particular. she's encountered at least a hundred (if not more?) physicians who have been distant, absent, and even downright cold. many have not been well-versed in their own specialty, let alone anything remote to it. one could argue, perhaps, that this is just one person's perspective. and, oh, how i wish that were true. but it isn't. i know because her words resonate with my experiences as a patient. her question--wanna be my doc?--has also been asked of me many times, by many friends (and even some strangers!) in similar situations. this is being asked. of me. the first-year medical student....

one of the reasons i am a first-year medical student, though, is because i feel the fire, the rage, the dissatisfaction shared by so many patients. it's an emotion that can't--indeed mustn't--be ignored. thus i'm left to wonder: given that i cannot be physician to the masses, given that i am human and will make mistakes during my career, given that i have to be able to take care of myself as well as those around me, given all the barriers present in healthcare, how can one person make a difference? how do i remain open to people, to learning, to the tenets of my profession when it seems that so many physicians give up, burn out, or sell out? and how do i become a decent physician if i can't manage my own healthcare problems? if i cannot take care of the people i love? if i pin the essence of primum non nocere to my heart, will i always remember?

once again, all i'm left with are questions.

speaking of which, hey j.p., wanna come to med school? ;-)

a little disclaimer...

i'm a medical student. just a student. so please, don't take anything i say too seriously. remember that i was an english literature major as an undergrad, so there is much fiction to be found in these pages. do you think i'm telling a story about you or your illness? more likely, you're tapping into my sense of "everyman"--that is, your story resonates with what i write here because it's not so uncommon after all. need help? please, please go see your physician. <--i'm not her. yet. ;-)